Twilight and Forgiveness: Shocker! A Man Forgives a Cheating Woman

Despite no official announcement from Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart, it is being reported that the young actor has forgiven his Twilight sweetheart. If this is true, and this is not just a promotion for their movie, then Pattinson will possibly be the first famous man of his generation to forgive a cheating woman.

I am not a fan of Twilight, and I am not personally invested in seeing the two get back together nor will I boil with hate in the event of a reconciliation. What I’m interested in is how this scandal reveals a gender-based skewed culture of forgiveness that we should examine and reflect upon.

A Huffington Post article “Trampire:” Why the Public Slut Shaming of Kristen Stewart Matters for Young Women by Nico Lang traces celebrity relationship mishaps, and points out that in many instances men are left unscathed despite cheating scandals and other grievous mistakes. The article says:

I might not be concerned for K-Stew, but I am concerned for all the young women today who are tuned into this scandal, ones who are learning that it’s not okay to screw up, ever. Chris Brown can publicly beat the hell out of his girlfriend but still be played on the radio and win Grammys. However, if you ever cheat on your boyfriend, your life is over and no one will ever want to be associated with you. Almost no one will blame the much-older guy you cheated with, and it might actually make him more famous and help his career. Few will care that he was your boss and in a position of authority or that he may have have taken advantage of your youth and relative inexperience. Everything is your fault, and your life will be threatened over it. If you are a trampire, you will be publicly staked for it, even though cheater Ashton Kutcher recently emerged relatively unscathed by the media. No one asked for him to be fired from Two and a Half Men.

The article’s discussion of the way the public forgives men more easily than women interested me, but I also want to examine forgiveness as a personal choice and how cultures of forgiveness differ between men and women.

I can’t say that forgiving a cheater is the right choice or the wrong choice. It’s really up to the person involved to make the final decision. I am not arguing that Pattinson should forgive Stewart, but if he has already genuinely forgiven her, then I celebrate his personal choice because it is rare to find famous men who have forgiven cheating women.

Although men are considered to have a higher tendency to cheat, they are the ones who lack the capacity to forgive when they’ve been cheated on. According to this article, six in ten women would forgive a man even if he has cheated twice, but only one in ten men would forgive a woman if she cheats once.

Forgiving someone is a personal choice, but sometimes our personal choices are influenced by the way we are socialized to believe in certain values or how we are raised to perceive certain behaviors as permissible or forgivable. These values are often reinforced by the people around us who give us advice during trying times.

When the scandal broke out, I remember reading an article which said that Pattinson’s friends (let’s assume they were male friends) were working hard to stop him from getting back together with Stewart.

A woman’s friends would not react the same way. Sure there will be those who will tell her to forget him, but some will ask, “Do you still love him? Can you still forgive him?” If they are already married, the woman’s friends will tell her to save her marriage. I wonder if male friends would tell the man to forgive his wife and work on the marriage for the sake of their children.

Ok, let’s do an experiment. Answer these two questions with either a yes or a no:

Question 1: Do you believe that cheating should never ever be forgiven?
Question 2: Are you a man?

I wonder: is there a higher chance that those people who say yes to the first question also say yes to the second? If so, why do men and women have different standards when it comes to forgiveness?

We must ask ourselves why it seems that men are allowed to make more mistakes than women. We must ask ourselves why society makes us believe that are men reform-able cheaters but women are unforgivable sluts.

King Henry the VIII of England had a string of wives and a larger throng of mistresses, but when his wives were accused or proven to be unfaithful, he had them beheaded. At least men have learned to stop killing women for infidelity, but even in this century are the fellas still jumping the gun?

More Analyze This:

Check out my other blog categories.

If you like this post, please subscribe to this blog. Ja is also on Twitter and FacebookTumblr, Bloglovin (for blogfor Tumblr). Email Ja at:

Note: For some entries in this blog, a few names and details have been deliberately and willingly changed by the author. This is a personal decision made by the author for specific reasons known to her and is not an endorsement for censorship.

All the opinions expressed in this page and in this blog are my own and do not represent the official stances of the companies, institutions, and organizations that I am affiliated with. I am a person. I’m not just a manifestation of corporate interests. I have an identity that is separate from those companies and other entities because even if human beings are paid for a service by corporations, human beings are not owned by corporations.


4 thoughts on “Twilight and Forgiveness: Shocker! A Man Forgives a Cheating Woman

  1. You are welcome, Ja. For sure, I agree that there is a double standard in most countries. Men should be forgiven or even allowed to engage in such behavior is the mindset among many, while women are often branded as women of ill repute.

    A number of male politicians are re-elected over and over despite having many children with several different women, all the while still being married to one! Can you imagine what would be the reaction if a lady politician engaged in the same behavior with many men?

    Being a womanizer when one is married is often glamorized and admired but I have only heard bad name calling if a woman is a manizer while she is still married. In many places, it is a macho society and women are expected to be lady-like.

    ~ Gary ~


    1. That is true. There are many politicians who have several wives or are known to be cheaters, but the public doesn’t criticize them that much. Yes I agree that some men even treat it like a badge of honor because it shows that they are irresistible to women, but if women do this, they’ll be slammed as sluts.


  2. This is really an interesting and serious topic since it happens somewhere everyday. Yes, I am a man. Yes, in some situations, a cheating partner can be forgiven.Whether the partner is male or female, when either one commits infidelity, it usually inflicts much sorrow and emotional pain on the other partner; especially if they have been in a long term love relationship.

    If the affair was a one time only fling, in the heat of the moment so to speak, I think more men, including me, would be willing to forgive and attempt continuing the relationship. However, if the affair had been going on for some time, the trust, the respect and the sanctity of the relationship has been seriously breached. Especially if the partner is sleeping with the main partner and the illicit partner during the same time on a longer term basis. That breach of trust and respect is almost impossible to ever repair in my opinion.

    I do not have the personal belief that it is fine for a man to cheat and wear it as a badge of merit and if the woman cheats, she should be branded with a scarlet letter. It is best to dissolve a relationship if one wants to play the field. That is usually much easier to accept than being a victim of a cheating partner. Infidelity has led to many murders and suicides the world over.

    One word of caution, please do not rely on tismis or gossip as a confirmation of a cheating partner. Some people have crab mentality and will not hesitate to try and destroy a relationship between two people that they themselves covet.

    ~ Gary ~


    1. Thank you Gary for sharing your opinion on this topic. It is true that there are men who are willing to forgive infidelity especially if it’s a one time thing. This is not to say that forgiving infidelity is the right choice for every person. What we need to examine though is the trend where more women forgive infidelity than men, and these women are often encouraged or even pressured by the people around them to forgive, but men are not under the same social pressures, so I wonder if this personal choice is being influenced by a gender-based culture of forgiveness, and that we need to be more aware of this kind of culture, we need to examine it, and try to figure out how it’s affecting our lives and our personal decisions.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s